Split-or-Join: Household Benefits Optimizer
Employer A
Employer B
Household
Methodology — the formula, in the open
For each configuration: True Cost = annual premiums + annual surcharges + expected out-of-pocket − employer HSA seed + best family dental + best family vision. Dental and vision are optimized separately (cheapest family premium across the two employers), because they are separate decisions — see our guide.
Expected out-of-pocket for a plan = the lesser of its out-of-pocket maximum and its deductible × the care multiplier you selected (Low 0.25, Typical 0.75, High 1.40). In two-plan configurations, each plan's expected out-of-pocket is weighted by the share of household members it covers (adults and children counted as three units). Configurations blocked by a spousal carve-out are removed and listed, not silently dropped.
Assumptions and limitations
- The model assumes both adults have an offer of coverage from their own employer (so surcharges and carve-outs apply as entered), and that children can be covered on either plan.
- It does not model copays, coinsurance tiers, provider networks, prescription formularies, or tax savings from HSA/FSA contributions — all of which can matter. It ranks on the costs most households can actually obtain from a rate sheet.
- Premiums are entered pre-tax as shown on employer rate sheets. Employer documents govern; this tool is an educational model, not benefits advice.
- The FSA/HSA warning reflects the general rule in IRS Publication 969: a general-purpose health FSA can make a spouse ineligible for HSA contributions. Limited-purpose FSAs are treated as compatible and do not trigger the warning logic beyond the checkbox you set.
Frequently asked questions
Why is “everyone on one plan” not always the winner?
Because employee-only tiers are usually the most heavily subsidized. Two employee-only premiums plus one employee-plus-children premium often cost less than one family premium — and each plan's deductible and HSA seed then work in parallel.
Does dual coverage ever win here?
It is ranked like everything else, at its true premium cost. Under non-duplication coordination of benefits the secondary plan often pays little, so dual coverage usually finishes last — the tool shows you by how much, for your numbers.
Is my data saved or sent anywhere?
No. The calculation runs entirely in this page. There is no account, no form submission, and no analytics attached to the values you enter.
Official documentation and references
- IRS Publication 969 — HSAs, FSAs and eligibility
- HealthCare.gov — Coordination of benefits
- HealthCare.gov — Open enrollment period
- CFPB — Choosing a health insurance plan
Educational disclaimer: This tool provides general educational estimates, not personalized benefits, tax, or financial advice. Verify elections against your employers' official plan documents before enrolling.